Experience
Well Done
& Crispy
The Best Pizza in Columbus
As Featured In
(click to watch or read)
Heads Up!
We sell out
Frequently.
We know. It’s not ideal. Especially since it’s the best pizza in Columbus.
It’s just that we make every batch of dough by hand and let it rise for 2 days for that perfect airy crust.
And the stone & brick ovens we use to create those crispy, gooey, mouth-wateringly delicious slices? They can only cook and hold so many pizzas each night!
We recommend ordering early and often. (But mostly early.)
Why So Tasty?
HAND-TOSSED DOUGH
Made from scratch, risen for 2 days
FRESHEST INGREDIENTS
Cut, shredded, and placed by hand
QUALITY OVER QUANTITY
We stop when the ingredients run out
NYC-STYLE PIES
Every slice is a piece of culinary tradition
UNIQUE TOPPINGS
Boring and bland have no place here
Original or Cauliflower Crust
Pick your favorite. There’s no wrong answer!
Round
Eight (8) NYC-style slices of hand-tossed heaven in every 16″ pie
Motown
Eight (8) squares of deep dish goodness in 10″ and 14″ widths
Pick Your Toppings
SPICY PEPPERONI
Cupped and slightly burnt rounds of joy, adding a spicy encore to your meal
WHOLE MILK MOZZARELLA
Rich whole milk mozzarella that strings along like a melty cheese guitar solo
FRESH BASIL LEAVES
A bright, refreshing high note of Mediterranean flavor on every slice
SAUSAGE CRUMBLE
Savory sausage that hits the taste buds with a symphony of spices
WHIPPED RICOTTA
Cloud-like whipped ricotta that’s smoother than a jazz flute solo
CANDIED BACON
1 + 1 = 3. A sweet surprise that’s the cherry on top of the pizza pie!
GARLIC
Garlic that brings a flavor punch as surprising as a magician’s trick
PARMESAN
Parmesan that rains down like confetti on your pizza parade
JALEPENO
Add a spark of excitement like fireworks on a flavor skyline
HOT HONEY
Mike’s Hot Honey sweetly sizzles like a summer night’s dream
PICKLES
A tangy twist and a crunch that steals the spotlight
SHREDDED MOZ
Our mozzarella shreds harder than a Van Halen solo
FRIED CHICKEN
The crispy up-beat to your modern pizza’s melody
ONION
A crisp, aromatic layer of intrigue to each slice
VEGAN CHEESE
Not a cheesy as a dad joke. But almost.
… and more
Favorite & Specialty Pizzas
These unique creations – though delicious in every way – are seasonal and may not be available at every location. Peep your store’s menu for details.
Classic Pepperoni
Legends never die. That’s why this one will be on our menu ’til infinity. Our charred take on this classic will have you begging for more.
Toppings
shredded mozzarella
Cupped Ezzo Pepperoni
Charred to perfection
Just Cheese
Say it with us: bubbles are beautiful. As CO2 gets trapped inside the dough, it creates crispy pockets of flavor.
Toppings
Dough
Sauce
Cheese
That’s It!
East Village Pepperoni
A slice of the bustling city life, this pizza combines iconic flavors in a timeless tribute to the vibrant East Village spirit.
Toppings
Fresh mozzarella
pepperoni
fresh basil
Kevin Bacon
Sizzle into a slice of this star-studded creation and experience the smoky sweetness of candied bacon.
Toppings
Whole milk mozzarella
pepperoni
candied bacon
MIKE!
A daring fusion of sweet and heat, this pizza mingles richness and heat for a thrilling taste adventure.
Toppings
Fresh mozzarella
whole milk mozzarella
pepperoni
Mike’s Hot Honey
basil
Smokey Robinson
Ignite your senses with this spicy, sweet pie that’s as soulful as its namesake and topped with a drizzle that’s to die for.
Toppings
Whole milk mozzarella
pepperoni
jalapeño
Mike’s Hot Honey
614
A tribute to its roots, this pie is a medley of bold and zesty flavors that capture the essence of its namesake area code.
Toppings
Pepperoni
bacon
banana peppers
Bee Bee Q
A hive of activity for your taste buds, this creation buzzes with a tangy-sweet barbecue twist that’s un-bee-lievably good.
TOPPINGS
Garlic
fried chicken
onion
ranch
bbq
Mike’s Hot Honey
What the Dilly Yo?!
A quirky twist on pizza that’s as surprising as its name—this one’s for the adventurous who enjoy a tangy kick with their slice.
Toppings
Garlic
whole milk mozzarella
pickles
parmesan
Hakuna Ricotta
A perfectly crafted pie that delivers creamy, savory, and fresh flavors in every bite—pure bliss, no worries required.
Toppings
Follow Your Heart Mozzarella Cheese Beyond Vegan Sausage Crumble
Tomato
Garlic Oil
Nashville Hot Chic
A bold and fiery creation with just the right kick, perfectly balanced by cool, tangy touches for a flavor-packed adventure in every bite.
TOPPINGS
Garlic base
Fried chicken
Pickles
Nashville Hot & Ranch drizzle
Margherita Pizza
A timeless classic with simple, fresh flavors that shine—elegantly crafted to perfection in every bite.
Toppings
Sliced mozz
Olive oil
Sea salt
Fresh basil
I'm Vegan
Ask me about it. I’ll tell you all about my “mozzarella cheese”, “sausage” crumble, fresh tomatoes, and garlic oil.
Toppings
Follow Your Heart Mozzarella Cheese Beyond Vegan Sausage Crumble
Tomato
Garlic Oil
Dairy Air
You can do side bends or sit-ups, but give this spicy pie a try before you knock it. Creamy and crunchy, all at once.
TOPPINGS
Ezzo pepperoni
cream cheese
Mike’s hot honey
White Pizza
A luscious blend of creamy ricotta, melty mozzarella, and savory parmesan on a garlic-kissed crust. Pure, cheesy bliss in every bite.
Toppings
Ricotta
Mozarella
Parmesan
Garlic Oil
Sauces
A little yum yum for the tum tum. Drizzle, dunk, splash, garnish, or glaze your solids with sauces so tasty they make Bobby Flay blush.
Homemade Ranch
Mike's Hot Honey
Classic BBQ
Nashville
Hot Honey BBQ
House Italian
Drinks
Wash down our epic eats with our lineup of liquid elixirs.
Soda Pop
Fountain Drinks
Beer
2-Liter Soda
Extras
The perfect sidekicks to your pizza feast, each a star in its own right.
⚡ Great Scott! ⚡
Non-pizza items are ONLY available at our Hilliard restaurant. Come visit!
Wings
Tommy likey… and so will you. Local bone-in and boneless. Buy ’em by the 5s or half-pound.
Hand-Cut Fries
Handcut taters deep-fried to perfection. Order ’em plain, garlic, or parmesan.
House Salad
For those seeking redemption from our cheese-laden sins, here’s your sanctuary of greens.
Cheese Stix
A crispy, deep-fried golden exterior gives way to a stretchy, cheese-filled treasure chest.
Fried Pickles
This tangy twist in a crunchy coat is the rill dill. Every bite is a crispy, zesty adventure.
Ranch Jar
Homemade and perfect for dipping, drinking straight from the can, and bathing in.
Choose wisely
Gahanna
943 E Johnstown Rd
Gahanna, OH 43230
Hours
Mon-Thurs | 3pm – 9pm
Fri & Sat | 11:30AM – 10PM
Sun | 12PM – 8pm
Harrison West
360 West 3rd Ave
Columbus, OH 43201
Hours
Mon- Thurs | 3pm – 9pm
Fri & Sat | 11:30AM – 10PM
Sun | 12PM – 8pm
Hilliard
5460 Franklin St
Hilliard, OH 43206
Hours
MON-THURS | 3PM – 9PM
FRI & SAT | 11:30AM – 10PM
SUN | 12PM – 8PM
Details Matter
CRAZY FRESH INGREDIENTS
HANDMADE DOUGH
PREMIUM PARTNERS
CHARRED, NOT BURNT
CRISPY BY DEFAULT
No two Sexton’s Pizzas are alike.
That’s because everything we do – from the vendors we work with to the way we make our pizzas – is focused on taste. Stone conveyors, deck ovens, top-shelf ingredients. They’re all here being assembled for you.
When big box flavor just won’t do.
Premium Ingredients
STANISLAUS TOMATOES
Picked only during peak season and moved from vine to can in under 6 hours, these tomatoes are the freshest.
NON-BROMATED FLOUR
Clean & simple. Our flour is non-bromated (additive-free) & non-GMO. There are only four ingredients in our dough – if you count water.
GRANDE CHEESES
Grande produces “the finest Italian cheeses money can buy.” How? They play their cows jazz music. We can’t make this stuff up.
BUTTERMILK RANCH
Our ranch in-house using the finest buttermilk, pepperco… um, sorry. If we told you the rest, one of our friends would have to pay you a little visit.
EZZO SAUSAGE COMPANY
Columbus-based, EZZO produces pepperoni & sausage for the country’s most talked about pizzerias.
Don’t Take Our Word for It
Just had it. Tasted great. I ordered at 4pm for a pizza at 7pm. I got there at 6:55pm they said it’d still be a couple of minutes. They pulled it out hot and fresh right at 7pm.
I will only order pizza from Sexton’s now… I was very hesitant to try their pizza because the pictures looked like burnt pizza. It’s not like an overcooked burnt but an edible, very delicious burnt.
This place is awesome, LOVE the crunch on every bite, the cheese isn’t greasy, and the pepperonis are perfect. We are going to make this place a weekly visit… staff was super friendly & pizza came out fast.
Alright Frankie, the crust is crispy, sauce is just right and the cheese is unbelievable. 8.3! So far best pizza in the Columbus Ohio area!Check it out!!!
We all loved the ladled on thick, occasionally caramelized sauce on this pizza which accentuated all of the positives of the greasy goblets of fatty meats holding down the cheese.
We got the Bee Bee Q (garlic sauce base, fried chicken, onion, with a hot honey bbq and ranch drizzle) and it was incredible. It was fluffy but crispy with a perfect balance of flavors. 10/10 would get again.
Leave Us a Review
Started from the Bottom Now We Here
In 2016, two veteran brothers – Joey and Jamey – bought a $6,000 food trailer and started their journey to make the crunchiest pizza in Ohio. The rest is history.
Still Here?